OrderMyChecks.com Reviews

OrderMyChecks.com has an overall rating of 2.9 based on 32 reviews. Customer feedback on OrderMyChecks.com is mixed: OrderMyChecks.com reviewers highlight positive aspects like easy online ordering, wide variety of designs, competitive pricing, and fast shipping, which strongly appeal to individuals and businesses looking for personalized checks. However, OrderMyChecks.com is often criticized for its limited customer service options, occasional printing errors, higher prices for custom designs, and slow response times.

2.9/5.0

32 reviews

5 Stars

4

4 Stars

6

3 Stars

4

2 Stars

3

1 Star

7

All OrderMyChecks.com Reviews (32)
dolores_Hartman97
May 14, 2026
"Good options for duplicate checks"
I ordered some duplicate checks and there were enough styles to choose from, which was nice. The site was easy to use, though I don’t remember exactly what I picked. Shipping took a little longer than I expected, but it all worked out fine.
Edmund-brown
May 11, 2026
"Easy to choose my starting check number"
I really liked that I was able to pick my starting check number without any hassle. The order process went smoothly and the checks arrived looking right. My only complaint is that the tracking wasn’t very clear, so I wasn’t totally sure where things stood. Did anyone else have that same issue with the tracking?
jeannequesada8202
May 11, 2026
"Pretty decent, and the register was a nice touch"
The checks seem fine so far, and I guess it was nice that a check register came with them. Nothing really stood out as amazing, but they do the job. Shipping took a little longer than I expected, though.
AaronMartinez_84
May 10, 2026
"Uploading my logo was somehow the hardest part"
I tried to order checks with my business logo, thinking it would be a quick little upload-and-done situation. Naturally, that was wildly optimistic. The site kept rejecting my file with these super vague error messages that basically told me something was wrong, while offering the helpful detail of absolutely nothing.

I resized the logo a few different ways and still couldn’t get the preview to look right. For a feature that sounds like it should be simple, it managed to turn into a whole project. Eventually I gave up and didn’t finish the order, which is probably not the goal of an ordering process
joycedixon3367
May 08, 2026
"I was ordering checks and figured I’d be..."
I was ordering checks and figured I’d be able to find a decent cover easily, but the selection was way smaller than I expected. There were barely any styles, and a lot of them looked kind of outdated or cheap. I thought there would at least be a few nicer options to choose from, but I ended up clicking around for a while and still couldn’t find anything I liked. Definitely disappointing.
REED
April 26, 2026
"Good checks, slow shipping?!"
The checks themselves came out fine, no complaints there. But the shipping was way slower than I expected?! I figured it would take a few days, not over a week with barely any updates. I kept checking the tracking and it just sat there for a while. Not the worst experience, but definitely frustrating if you need your checks soon
Michaela_enriquez04
April 22, 2026
"Checks felt cheap and poorly printed"
I ordered these checks expecting them to be about the same quality as my old ones, but this batch really didn’t give me much confidence. The paper felt thin, the printing looked kind of fuzzy, and a few of the edges were cut rough.

If this order is any sign of their usual quality, I wouldn’t feel comfortable ordering from them again. I don’t really want to use checks that look this cheap, so for me it ended up feeling like a waste of money.
Michael_buskey89
April 15, 2026
"Decent checks, but double-check the preview"
I ordered some personal checks from ordermychecks.com, and overall it was a smooth experience. They had a decent selection of simple designs, and I found one that looked clean and normal enough for paying bills.
Just a heads up though, the preview part was a little confusing at first, so don’t rush through it. My order showed up fine and I don’t really have any major complaints, but I’d definitely recommend checking everything carefully before placing the order.
Vincent_mayberry05
April 10, 2026
"I tried ordering checks through the site..."
I tried ordering checks through the site, and it felt way harder than it should have. There were too many steps, pages were loading slow, and I kept wondering if my information actually saved correctly. I almost thought I had it figured out, actually, no, I ended up giving up once and had to start all over. Definitely not an easy process
hello_jaime084
March 30, 2026
"Found my order history, but it took a minute"
I was trying to look up an old check order and I did find it eventually, so that part was fine. It just took me a little while to figure out where everything was... The site feels a bit outdated and kinda slow, honestly. It worked in the end, just not the easiest experience...
SMITH
March 16, 2026
"Super helpful customer service"
I had a little issue with my check order, so I called customer service not really knowing how it would go. The woman I spoke with was really friendly and got everything sorted out fast. She explained what happened clearly and was patient with my questions, which I really appreciated. My order turned out just fine in the end. Overall, it was a good experience and I’d definitely use them again.
gaylamartinez5227
March 13, 2026
"Had to check with my bank first"
The checks ended up being fine, but I did have to double check my bank info before I felt good about it. It wasn’t super clear at first, kinda confusing but it all worked out fine in the end.
ThomasAngelico
March 12, 2026
"For some reason, the address label options were..."
For some reason, the address label options were really limited, and most of them just looked kind of ugly to me. I was expecting a few more decent designs to choose from.
JaredJohnson_20
March 04, 2026
"Finally Didn’t Feel Ripped Off for Checks"
I ordered checks from here mostly because my bank wanted way more money, and it felt like I was getting punished just for needing basic checks. This site was easy to use, and for once I didn’t feel like someone was trying to sneak in a bunch of extras I don’t need. Shipping took about the normal amount of time, and the checks look totally fine. For the price, I’m actually happy with it.
Carolyn.denham
March 02, 2026
"Not many good font or monogram choices"
I was disappointed with the font and monogram options on OrderMyChecks.com. The fonts just weren’t great — a lot of them looked outdated, and some were kind of hard to read. I kept looking through them thinking I’d find something better, but it was basically the same issue over and over. The monogram choices were limited too, like really limited. I wanted the checks to feel a little more personal, but the options just felt boring. I ended up ordering anyway because I needed checks, but if I wanted anything custom again, I probably wouldn’t use them...
Owen_gascho02
February 28, 2026
"I ordered checks and noticed they..."
I ordered checks and noticed they printed one of the numbers wrong. It made me nervous because with something like checks, you really don’t want to feel like you might get stuck paying for a mistake or be fooled into accepting something that isn’t right. Frustrating experience.
miguel_Rogers77
February 27, 2026
"Ordering checks wasn’t too difficult, but the…"
Ordering checks wasn’t too difficult, but the website definitely feels a little old. A few pages were slow to load and I had to go back and double check a couple steps before I finished. It all worked out in the end, just wasn’t the smoothest experience
RalphLaso
February 22, 2026
"Easy deposit slip order with good options"
I needed deposit slips for my small business, and ordermychecks.com actually had more choices than I thought they would.

I liked being able to pick a style that matched my checks and fill in my info without feeling like I was going to mess something up, if that makes sense. The site was straightforward to use.

The shipping was fine, and the deposit slips showed up looking right. I didn’t have any issues with the order, so I’d use them again.
Alex-christain
February 02, 2026
"Seemed Legit and Worked Out Fine"
I figured the site was secure enough when I placed my order, and thankfully everything showed up fine. It did take a little longer than I expected, so I kind of assumed there might be an issue at first, but it all worked out. I’d probably order from them again.
stelladiemer2793
January 30, 2026
"I was just trying to order checks, but..."
I was just trying to order checks, but I got hung up on the account info verification part. Like, I totally get that they need to confirm stuff, but the whole thing felt kind of clunky and not super clear.
A few of my details were definitely right, but the site kept making me re-enter things without really saying what was wrong. After a while I started wondering if I was messing something up, even though I dont think I was.

The order did finally go through later, so it wasn’t a complete disaster or anything. But it took way longer than it should have, and it made me trust the site a little less than before

View More Reviews

Have a question about OrderMyChecks.com?
ordermychecks

OrderMyChecks.com Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.